Does the new inspection framework trade off reliability against validity? – David Didau – Education Article

Yesterday I saw a thread on Twitter from headteacher Stuart Lock on the pros and cons of the new inspection framework: I realised in reading the discussion on twitter today what my problems are with the new @Ofstednews framework but why I think those issues were inevitable – and why it’s still the right bet. — Stuart Lock (@StuartLock) January 12, 2020 In it he discusses the idea that because the previous inspection framework relied heavily on schools’  results in…

Read More

a recommendation for improving Ofsted inspections – David Didau – Education Article

Mistakes in aviation are potentially catastrophic; when we get things wrong in teaching, no one dies. But the same pressures that cause pilots to make mistakes are at work to prevent teachers and school leaders acting in the best interest of their students, and maybe causing inspection teams to making avoidable mistakes in judging schools. I recently spent some time listening to some concerns about the inspection of Bilton School. According to Ofsted, the school is inadequate because there are…

Read More

Ofsted casts a dark shadow over schools | Letters | Education

Laura McInerney misses the point in her defence of Ofsted (How doubling the number of Ofsted inspections could make headteachers happier, Education, 18 February). The inspectorate has lasted a long time – but Matthew Arnold would be unable to recognise Her Majesty’s Inspectorate in its current form. Ofsted casts a dark shadow over schools. It is an important part of a toxic accountability system which drives teachers from the profession – nearly a third now leave within three years, citing…

Read More

Downing tools in protest is not the way to solve headteachers’ Ofsted problems | Laura McInerney | Education

School inspections in England began in 1839 – they are older than the zip, toilet paper, or tea bags. But for the first time in the inspectorate’s history it is facing a major and potentially destabilising problem: school leaders are politely withdrawing their labour. A few years ago, Ofsted decided that instead of grading schools using inspectors who had never worked in one, it should recruit more school leaders; they would be employed part-time for the inspectorate, and as senior…

Read More

Ofsted chief: funding cuts forcing schools to narrow curriculum | Education

Schools are cutting back the curriculum and not replacing teachers when they leave because of a growing funding crisis, the chief inspector of schools has said. In an unprecedented step, Ofsted’s Amanda Spielman laid out the impact of cuts in a blogpost that has since been removed because it was published “erroneously”. It will be published again in the coming weeks, along with a more detailed study on school funding. Spielman has previously been criticised after she said it would…

Read More

An Ofsted inspection should not be like entering the dragons’ den | Letters | Education

What a disturbing account of disgraceful Ofsted inspections in your report (Outstanding primaries fail their Ofsted under new rules, 4 February). The Office for Standards in Education could have been valuable if it had treated teachers respectfully as fellow professionals to be inspected cordially, challenged where necessary, and guided and supported when appropriate. But instead, throughout its 28 years of existence, it has engendered fear in those inspected, and, where it found fault, conveyed its criticisms to public and parents…

Read More

Outstanding primary schools fail Ofsted inspections under sudden rule switch | Education

The eight-year-old boy was meeting the Ofsted inspector for the first time. “What do you remember learning in history?” she asked, tapping on her iPad. It was months since his year did the subject but he thought of something: “The Vikings.” And what did he learn about the Vikings? “They invented dragons,” he replied. Under the inspectorate’s new framework, introduced last September, anecdotal evidence of what children say appears to be taking centre stage. The child’s reply about Viking imagery…

Read More

Ofsted uncovers 500 suspected illegal schools in England | Education

More than 500 suspected illegal schools, educating thousands of pupils, have been identified in England over the past three years by the schools watchdog Ofsted, according to data published for the first time. Some of the schools were in an appalling condition with rat traps, exposed wires and open sewers, Ofsted inspectors said. In one, pupils were left to play computer games all day, while in another inspectors found children in every classroom repeating religious texts with no other apparent…

Read More

Ofsted staff to wear body cameras to visit suspected illegal schools | Education

Ofsted inspectors raiding suspected illegal schools in England are to be given body-worn cameras for the first time to improve efforts to shut them down, the watchdog has announced. Staff belonging to Ofsted’s illegal schools taskforce will wear digital video recorders similar to those used by police officers. The taskforce was set up to investigate groups operating without registering as a school, which may not be following safeguarding or child protection regulations, and lack oversight of teaching and facilities. Ofsted…

Read More

Birmingham Islamic school sues Ofsted after being failed for leaflet | Education

An Islamic school in Birmingham has mounted a legal challenge against Ofsted after it was failed by the educational watchdog over a 25-year-old “inflammatory” leaflet. Birchfield independent girls’ school in Aston was rated as “inadequate” by Ofsted after inspectors found a leaflet about a 1994 Islamic conference in the library. The school was predicted to get a “good” judgment until the discovery during the second day of the inspection, the Birmingham Mail. Inspectors said: “The leaflet states: ‘Today we find…

Read More

Ofsted boss hits out at schools for continuing to ‘game’ league tables | Education

The head of Ofsted has issued a sharp rebuke to schools in England that continue to “off-roll” vulnerable pupils and force others to take “sham qualifications” in order to maximise results and improve league table positions. The schools watchdog introduced a new inspection framework last year aimed at encouraging schools to move away from a purely results-driven culture and focus instead on a broad, rich curriculum. However, according to the chief inspector of schools, Amanda Spielman, a minority of schools…

Read More

Outstanding schools to lose exemption from Ofsted inspections | Education

Outstanding schools in England will no longer be exempt from routine Ofsted inspections, education secretary Gavin Williamson has announced. The move is one of several government measures intended to bolster education standards. The new, expanded inspection programme aims to ensure that parents get up-to-date information and can be confident that schools rated outstanding continue to provide the highest standards, said Williamson. “Every parent wants to know their child is getting a great education and I will leave no stone unturned…

Read More

I’ve been a head for 17 years. Now Ofsted has driven me out of the job I loved | Education

Teacher Lynne Fox received a prestigious Pearson national headteacher of the year award last summer. Judges praised her as a “tour de force” who had transformed her comprehensive, Bramhall high school, overcoming significant challenges such as funding cuts and staff redundancies to secure “the very best educational experience for students”. The school, they said, was “a vibrant environment where enthusiasm and creativity are encouraged”, leading to “outstanding” results. A few weeks later, Fox found herself leaving a meeting with Ofsted…

Read More

Everyone welcome: inside the schools that haven’t expelled a child since 2013 | Education

Jason Thurley, headteacher at Beacon academy, near Grimsby, leans across the table explaining why yet another of his pupils was excluded before joining the school. “He’d brought in a £1 potato gun. It was at the bottom of his bag and so he goes up to his form tutor and says, ‘I don’t want to get into trouble with this, sir, can you take it?’ And he gets permanently excluded. The school said ‘we have a zero-tolerance policy on firearms’.”…

Read More

Ofsted to bring back routine inspections for outstanding schools | Education

Outstanding schools and colleges in England are to be stripped of their exemption from regular inspections, overturning a policy introduced by the former education secretary Michael Gove. The Department for Education said that from September it plans to return to a five-year cycle of inspections for state schools rated by Ofsted as outstanding , fulfilling an election promise by the Conservatives and an earlier pledge by the education secretary, Gavin Williamson. Since 2012, schools with an outstanding rating have been…

Read More

Ofsted report says 200,000 pupils stuck in low achieving schools | Education

More than 200,000 pupils in England are being educated in schools that have performed poorly for at least 13 years, despite being inundated with improvement initiatives from central and local government, a report shows. The schools’ regulator Ofsted has identified 415 “stuck” schools, in all phases of education, that have received persistently poor inspection ratings and have been locked in a cycle of low performance for so long they have potentially failed two whole cohorts of children. Ofsted defines stuck…

Read More